Full Review
The Story So Far
SM Entertainment has stirred controversy with its decisions for SMTOWN Live 2025 in Seoul. The Remake Stage artist line-up has sparked outrage among fans due to the inclusion of SHINee’s Jonghyun for a song remake. Let’s dive into the details of why fans are expressing their discontent.
Fans Express Discontent
Netizens were quick to voice their displeasure over the choice to include Jonghyun in the lineup for a song remake. Many felt that SM Entertainment had not adequately honored Jonghyun’s legacy or made his music easily accessible to fans. The decision to feature his song in a remake was met with criticism and disappointment.
Twitter Reactions
Now I’m pissed off you wouldn’t give Jonghyun the time of day in his career in SHINee’s career you intentionally withhold content, and never acknowledge him except for 2 days out of the 365 but now you wanna have people covering his songs for your anniversary performance
— the gigashawol™ (@kibumiist) January 7, 2025
Many fans expressed frustration over SM Entertainment’s lack of recognition for Jonghyun’s contributions and the sudden decision to use his work for their anniversary performance. The move was perceived as insincere by fans who have long awaited more acknowledgment of Jonghyun’s artistry.
Controversy Continues
Despite some fans being more accepting of the idea of a cover performance, the overall sentiment remained negative. Fans believed that any artist covering Jonghyun’s song should have a significant connection to him, while others questioned the necessity of a remake without the artist’s consent.
Conclusion
The backlash faced by SM Entertainment over the inclusion of Jonghyun in the Remake Stage artist line-up for SMTOWN Live 2025 highlights the deep emotional connection fans have with the late artist’s music. The controversy underscores the importance of honoring artists’ legacies with sincerity and respect.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why are fans upset with SM Entertainment’s decision for SMTOWN Live 2025?
Fans are unhappy with the choice to include Jonghyun in the lineup for a song remake, citing a lack of proper acknowledgment of his legacy.
2. How did netizens express their discontent?
Netizens took to social media platforms like Twitter to voice their frustration over the decision and SM Entertainment’s treatment of Jonghyun’s music.
3. What were fans’ reactions to the announcement?
Fans expressed disappointment and anger at the perceived insensitivity of using Jonghyun’s work for a remake without adequate recognition of his legacy.
4. What do fans believe should have been done differently?
Many fans felt that SM Entertainment should have honored Jonghyun’s legacy in a more meaningful way rather than using his music for a commercial performance.
5. How has SM Entertainment responded to the backlash?
As of now, SM Entertainment has not issued a public response to the controversy surrounding the Remake Stage artist line-up for SMTOWN Live 2025.
6. What impact does this controversy have on fans and the industry?
The controversy highlights the importance of respecting artists’ legacies and the emotional connection fans have with their favorite artists’ work.
7. Will this affect the attendance or reception of SMTOWN Live 2025?
It remains to be seen how fans will respond to the event and whether the controversy will impact attendance or the overall reception of the show.
8. How can SM Entertainment address fans’ concerns moving forward?
SM Entertainment could consider engaging with fans, acknowledging their feedback, and taking steps to honor Jonghyun’s legacy more meaningfully in the future.
9. What can other entertainment companies learn from this situation?
Other companies can learn the importance of respecting artists, their legacies, and the sentiments of fans when making decisions regarding their work.
10. What are the broader implications of this controversy for the music industry?
This controversy raises questions about the ethical use of an artist’s work posthumously and the responsibility of entertainment companies to honor artists’ legacies with integrity.
Tags:
SM Entertainment, SMTOWN Live 2025, Jonghyun, SHINee, Controversy, Legacy, Fan Backlash